Digital source criticism in the 21st century

06-201611-2018

RANKE 2.0

Source criticism is a vital part of historians’ work, and it generally features in all historiography syllabuses. But how should historians approach the many digital sources that are now available to them online via countless servers – sources that often have no paper version and no precise archive location to help trace their origins and verify their authenticity?

It has become vital for historians to develop new critical methods that take into account the specific nature of these archives. With its focus on digital history, the C²DH has a major role to play in helping address these highly important methodological issues.

Stefania Scagliola is working on the development of a digital platform to host resources for teaching about digital source criticism, based on the general source criticism methods taught at universities. “We need to differentiate between born-digital sources and documents that started off in another form and have subsequently been digitised,” explains the researcher. The digitisation process differs depending on the type of source, which may vary greatly. Sources come in the form of texts, photos and audiovisual material and include not just websites but also emails and social media posts. Future developments will doubtless result in the emergence of yet more formats.

The platform is primarily geared towards undergraduate and postgraduate students. It has several levels: an animation that is accessible to all users and serves as a general introduction to the topic; lessons followed by exercises, some of which are relatively advanced; and a workshop for group work. The modular design also means that it can be easily adapted for upper secondary school pupils. “Teachers and lecturers will find all the information they need to produce their own lessons, without needing to stick rigidly to the structure suggested on the platform,” adds Stefania Scagliola.

Lectures and presentations

Blog written after a guest lecture about digital source criticism to Bachelor students in History at the University of Luxembourg

c2dh.uni.lu/ ... histoire-de-luxembourg

Presentation about the platform at DH Benelux in June 2017 in The Hague 

Teaching activities

Guest lecture for the Source Criticism course run by Prof. Michel Margue — May 2017

Skills training — 2-day workshop in digital source criticism for Doctoral Training Unit — October 2017 

Guest lecture for the Family Connections in Early Modern Period course run by Dr Sonja Kmec — November 2017

Guest lecture for the Jewish Responses to Antisemitism course by Dr Gerben Zaagsma — December 2017

see also

BLIZAAR

Hybrid Visualisation of Dynamic Multilayer Graphs

BLIZAAR is a research project on novel visualisation techniques for data generated in the fields of humanities and biology.

read more

Digital History and Hermeneutics DTU

Doctoral Training Unit on Digital History and Hermeneutics: Where new ideas thrive!

The field of digital humanities opens up a host of new possibilities for advancing knowledge in traditional humanities disciplines.

read more

FAMOSO - Fabricating Modern Societies

The “Age of Steel” in Luxembourg revisited. Technologies of utopian capitalism and the making of national identity

The idea for the FAMOSO projects originated in May 2010 when Dr Karin Priem, the principal investigator of the FAMOSO projects, was introduced to a huge holding of 2,251 glass plates archived at the Centre national de l’audiovisuel (CNA) in Dudelange.

read more

histograph

Graph-based exploration and crowd-based indexation for multimedia collections

Multimedia collections can provide researchers and the general public with vast quantities of written and audiovisual material – but exploring these reams of data in an effective way is not always an easy task.

read more

impresso – Media monitoring the past

How to leverage the vast potential of historical newspapers

Historical newspapers are an essential source for scientific research, and new digitisation techniques can facilitate access to this material.

read more

The Luxembourg nation and the Jews (1930s to 1950s)

A microhistorical approach

The persecution of the Jews by the Nazi regime occurred in occupied Luxembourg virtually throughout the Second World War.

read more

Éischte Weltkrich

A virtual exhibition on the Great War in Luxembourg

The initiatives for the Great War Centenary have offered an unprecedented chance to re-engage with an important but understudied period in Luxembourgish history. Based on research carried out by historians at the University of Luxembourg and with the support of the Ministry of State, in February 2016 the C²DH began developing a digital exhibition on the Great War in Luxembourg.

read more